DESIGN PATENT PRO
  • Home
  • Cases
  • Law
  • Prosecution
  • Litigation
Patent Trial and Appeal Board Cases and Decisions

TABLE OF CONTENTS

AIA Trial Cases and Decisions (Inter Partes Review and Post Grant Review)
PTAB Regular Appeal Decisions
​PTAB Board Decisions Search (Trials and Appeals)
PTAB Reexamination Decision
PTAB Reissue Decisions

Pending AIA Cases (Inter Partes Review and Post Grant Review)

11/09/2021    Laltitude, LLC v. Altus Holdings Incorporated IPR of '138    IPR2022-00155    Pending Institution Decision
10/26/2021    Termax Company v. Illinois Tool Works Inc. IPR of '826    IPR2022-00106    Pending Institution Decision
09/15/2021    IdeaVillage Products Corp. v. Koninklijke Philips N.V. PGR of '346    PGR2021-00116    Pending Institution Decision
06/09/2021    Sattler Tech Corp. v. Yaqi Lyu PGR of '645    PGR2021-00095    Pending Institution Decision

 AIA Trial Cases and Decisions (Inter Partes Review and Post Grant Review)

Color Key:  Pending Institution   Institution Denied   Pending Final Decision   Final Decision    ​    
  
2021

11/09/2021    Laltitude, LLC v. Altus Holdings Incorporated IPR of '138    IPR2022-00155
10/26/2021    Termax Company v. Illinois Tool Works Inc. IPR of '826    IPR2022-00106
09/15/2021    IdeaVillage Products Corp. v. Koninklijke Philips N.V. PGR of '346    PGR2021-00116
06/09/2021    Sattler Tech Corp. v. Yaqi Lyu PGR of '645    PGR2021-00095


2020

Cell-Pak, Inc. v. Mambate USA, IPR2021-00007  (PTAB Oct 1, 2020)  USD846728  Adverse Judgment After Institution
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00055 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD855508
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00054 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD864065
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00823 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD837105
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00821 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD813759
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00536 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD797624
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00534 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD797625
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00530 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD813755
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00022 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD850341
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00020 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD852099
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00024 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD859253
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00021 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD853903
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00023 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD859246


2019

LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00064 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD823741 (Final Decision) (Hearing) (Unpatentable)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00004 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD840306
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00065 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD813120 (Withdrawn)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00062 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD811964
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00003 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD847703
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00002 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD847043

LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00063 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD828255 (Withdrawn)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00005 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD841532 
Sattler Tech Corp. v. HumanCentric Ventures LLC, PGR2019-00030 (PTAB Jan. 15, 2019) USD823093
Man Wah Holdings, Ltd. v. Raffel Systems LLC, IPR2019-00530 (PTAB Jan. 13, 2019) USD643252
Man Wah Holdings, Ltd. v. Raffel Systems LLC, PGR2019-00029 (PTAB Jan. 4, 2019) USD821986

2018

Levitation Arts, Inc. v. Flyte LLC, PGR2018-00073 (PTAB July 3, 2018) USD799100
MacSports Incorporated v. IDEA Nuova Incorporated, IPR2018-01006 (PTAB May 2, 2018) USD752890

2017

C&D Zodiac Incorporated v. B/E Aerospace, Inc., PGR2017-00019 (PTAB April 10, 2017) USD764031
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00607 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD696853
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00608 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD707032
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00619 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD725356
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00617 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723772
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00621 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723781
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00620 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723783
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc. , IPR2017-00623 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD725359

2016

Key-Bar, LLC v. Curv Group, LLC et al, PGR2017-00006 (PTAB Nov. 18, 2016) USD754427
Emerg, LC et al v. Fatboy The Original BV, PGR2017-00004 (PTAB Nov. 17, 2016) USD764823
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00096 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD595074
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00095 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD621644
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00091 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD621645
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00094 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD612646
David's Bridal, Inc. v. Jenny Yoo Collection, Inc., PGR2016-00041 (PTAB Sept. 8, 2016) USD744723
Galaxia Electronics Co., Ltd v. Revolution Display, LLC et al, PGR2016-00021 (PTAB May 18, 2016) USD736750
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01045 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD707032
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01043 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD696853
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01044 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD700423
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00875 (PTAB April 12, 2016) USD723783
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00870 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD725356
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00874 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD723781
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00872 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD723772
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00871 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD725359
Graco Children's Products, Inc. v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00826 (PTAB Mar. 31, 2016) USD616231
Graco Children's Products, Inc. et al v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00816 (PTAB Mar. 30, 2016) USD604970
Graco Children's Products, Inc. et al v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00810 (PTAB Mar. 29, 2016) USD570621
Aristocrat Technologies v. IGT et al, IPR2016-00767 (PTAB Mar. 16, 2016) USD503951
Premier Gem Corp. et al v. Wing Yee Gems & Jewelery Limited et al, IPR2016-00434 (PTAB Jan. 7, 2016) USD618132

2015

Johns Manville Corporation et al v. Knauf Insulation, Inc. et al, IPR2016-00130 (PTAB Nov. 2, 2015) USD631670
Johns Manville Corporation et al v. Knauf Insulation, Inc. et al, IPR2015-01453 (PTAB June 19, 2015) USD631670
Vitro Packaging LLC v. Saverglass Incorporated, IPR2015-00947 (PTAB Mar. 26, 2015) USD526197

2014

Caterpillar Incorporated v. Miller International Incorporated, IPR2015-00416 (PTAB Dec. 22, 2014) USD673982
Lowes Home Centers Incorporated v. Maureen Reddy, IPR2015-00306 (PTAB Nov. 25, 2014) USD677423
Dorman Products Incorporated v. PACCAR Incorporated, IPR2014-00555 (PTAB Mar. 28, 2014) USD526429
Dorman Products Incorporated v. PACCAR Incorporated, IPR2014-00542 (PTAB Mar. 26, 2014) USD525731

2013

Medtronic Incorporated v. NuVasive, Inc., IPR2014-00071 (PTAB Oct. 16, 2013) USD652922
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00580 (PTAB Sept. 11, 2013) USD686447
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00500 (PTAB Aug. 7, 2013) USD669731
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00501 (PTAB Aug. 7, 2013) USD675864
ATAS International Incorporated v. Centria, Inc., IPR2013-00259 (PTAB April 30, 2013) USD527834

2012

Munchkin Incorporated et al v. Luv n' Care Limited, IPR2013-00072 (PTAB Dec. 5, 2012) ​USD617465

PTAB Regular Appeal Decisions

Proceeding     Application  Appellant         Decision     Date          Issues

2021

2021002735   29641286    HFA, Inc.          Reversed     4-15-2021  (Obviousness - Primary prior art reference not basically the same)
2020001447   35502286    Weiss Umwelttechnik GmbH    Affirmed    03-16-2021 (Lack of Written Description and Indefiniteness of computer icons)
​
2020

2019002498    35500407    Flos s.p.a.    Reversed    10-26-2020  
2019002407    35500409    Flos s.p.a.    Reversed    10-21-2020
2019004375    29570334    Bredemeier, Lori A. et al.    Reversed    07-16-2020  (Reversal of Section 112 written description rejection based on alleged new matter)
2019004511    29543707    Honda Motor Co., Ltd.    Reversed    07-10-2020
2019007012    29619971    Bliss Hammocks Inc.    Reversed    07-07-2020
2019006598    29361552    Shawn Fojtik    Reversed    06-02-2020
2018007626    29543700    George Bucher et al.    Reversed    05-26-2020
2019004749    29572562    Amazon Technologies, Inc.    Reversed    05-21-2020
2019004293    29598496    Eichler, Mark Joseph.    Reversed    05-01-2020
2019004315    29531964    Amazon Technologies, Inc.    Reversed    04-24-2020
2018007433    29580932    Jay Sato et al.    Reversed    03-31-2020
2019001458    29515499    Perez, Jose    Reversed    03-30-2020
2019002084    29453864    Jaewoong Chung    Reversed    03-27-2020
2019003730    29535082    Piper, Neal    Reversed    03-27-2020
2018007742    29430805    Antonio Chioccioni    Reversed    03-24-2020  (Reversal of Section 112 indefiniteness and non-enabling rejection)
2019002406    29525529    Paul W. Adam    Affirmed    03-20-2020 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2019001727    29534975    Fong, Alena Rose. et al.    Reversed    01-27-2020
2018001761    29360842    Michael O. English et al.    Reversed    01-17-2020
2019001591    29547573    Salas, Luis F. et al.    Reversed    01-03-2020
2019001551    29547564    Salas, Luis F. et al.    Reversed    01-03-2020

2019

2018005551    29408999    Birgers, Christopher J. et al.    Reversed    12-31-2019
2018005678    29409740    Birgers, Christopher J. et al.    Reversed    12-31-2019
2018003279    29453426    Vittorio Bologna et al.    Affirmed    12-27-2019
2019000370    29509362    Yasutomi, Hiroshi et al.    Affirmed    12-19-2019 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2018001766    29443590    Imran Chaudhri et al.    Reversed    12-19-2019
2019001875    29541104    Apple Inc.    Reversed    12-18-2019
2018001345    29495451    Juan Almajid    Affirmed    10-23-2019 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2019001548    29547557    Salas, Luis F. et al.    Reversed    10-01-2019
2019001547    29547549    Salas, Luis F. et al.    Reversed    10-01-2019
2019001578    29547546    SALAS, LUIS F. et al.    Reversed    10-01-2019
2019001549    29547559    Salas, Luis F. et al.    Reversed    10-01-2019
2019001546    29547547    Salas, Luis F. et al.    Reversed    10-01-2019
2018006442    29497580    Ahren Bonnema et al.    Reversed    09-26-2019
2018004712    29461783    Danielle Giza    Reversed    09-24-2019
2019001776    29522397    Mohageg, Mike et al.    Reversed    09-20-2019
2019001901    29494441    Mariet, Robertus Christianus Elisabeth. et al.    Reversed    09-19-2019
2019001900    29461780    Giza, Danielle    Reversed    09-17-2019

2018

2017004757    14012735    Matt Alirol    Affirmed    01-16-2018

2017

2016000765    10943433    Richard E. Fulton et al    Affirmed-in-Part    08-21-2017
2014001032    29275866    Jennifer L. Sadler et al    Reversed    02-22-2017

2016

2013003740    29379528    Joseph P. Schultz    Reversed    06-30-2016
2014002624    29283341    Robert Ball    Reversed    04-18-2016
2014001432    29336285    Kathleen H. WITSIL et al    Reversed    03-08-2016
2014001431    29336284    Kathleen H. WITSIL et al    Reversed    03-08-2016
2014001433    29336290    Kathleen H. WITSIL et al    Reversed    03-08-2016

2015

2012012651    29370780    Jiaolong Chen    Reversed    08-31-2015

2014

2011011390    11000849    Geoff Smith et al    Reversed    03-31-2014

2012

2010002075    29237687    Bartley K. Andre et al    Reversed    04-19-2012
2010005623    29289864    Christopher J. Terrels et al    Reversed    02-21-2012

2011

2010001119    29276899    LARS ROSAEN    Reversed    12-19-2011
2010000696    29176577    Robert J. Libman et al    Reversed    11-02-2011
2009013647    29176106    Jamie L. Wheat    Reversed    06-20-2011

2010

2010002291    29271282    Peter M.H. Hung    Reversed    09-07-2010
2009010416    29264402    Jamie Chauss et al    Reversed    08-31-2010
2009012678    29212644    Paul Lacotta et al    Reversed    06-02-2010
2010000272    29196576    Allison M. Hart et al    Reversed    04-06-2010
2009009601    29241338    Aaron Charles Cueto    Reversed    01-22-2010

2009

2009009310    29302817    Robert Finch Kellermann et al    Reversed    10-22-2009
2009009305    29302816    Robert Finch Kellermann et al    Reversed    10-21-2009
2009005005    29244885    Troutman, Damon Oliver Casati. et al.    Reversed    09-23-2009
2009010408    29236287    Stefano Bettocchi    Reversed    09-15-2009
2009002192    10943433    Richard E. Fulton et al    Reversed    07-31-2009
2009010242    29192232    Philip W. Wyers    Reversed    07-20-2009
2008005555    29226865    Gordon E. VerWeyst    Reversed    03-25-2009
2008005613    29196598    Robert T. Mitten et al    Reversed    02-26-2009

2008

2008002254    29222088    Makoto Ishii et al    Reversed    11-26-2008
2008002270    29174064    Frank Howard Schaller    Reversed    06-02-2008
2007004521    29177452    Scott M. Risdon et al    Reversed    01-29-2008

2007

2007001759    29206334    Michael K. Kuehne et al    Reversed    07-11-2007

2006

2006000475    29158008    Richard B. Manville    Reversed    02-27-2006

2004

2004001452    29138830    William K. Stout JR.    Reversed    08-31-2004
2004001305    29138829    William K. Stout JR.    Reversed    08-27-2004
2004000152    29149571    Stefan Sagmeister et al    Reversed    03-15-2004
2004000401    29160956    Charles Pomeroy et al    Reversed    02-25-2004
2003001862    29153657    Stuart J. Ledingham    Reversed    01-29-2004

2003

2003001760    29159145    Arthur Miller    Reversed    09-26-2003
2003000656    29124773    Richard A. Cruz    Reversed    03-27-2003
2001000261    29066640    None    Reversed    02-27-2003
2002001818    29094432    COUNTEE    Reversed    01-16-2003
2003000007    29092219    DEWALD    Reversed    01-16-2003
2002002307    29105570    BERTIERI    Reversed    01-10-2003
1999001013    29014141    FRATTAROLA    Affirmed    01-03-2003

2002

2003000043    29065720    JAMES A. RIEDL    Reversed    11-26-2002
2002002156    29113438    KEMP et al    Reversed    11-19-2002
2001000292    29076553    KRUNAS    Reversed    10-31-2002
2001000961    08108133    DUKE    Reversed    10-30-2002
2000002150    29083483    MCGOVERN et al    Reversed    07-29-2002

2001

2001002294    29097935    VITTORIO GRAZIOLI    Reversed    12-17-2001
2001000337    29091083    GOLDEN et al    Reversed    08-29-2001
2000002151    29099783    NOSELLA    Reversed    05-22-2001
2001000467    29100490    BERTANI    Reversed    05-11-2001
2001000466    29112628    ROWAN    Reversed    04-26-2001
2000002183    29082343    GRANT    Reversed    04-23-2001
1999001567    29035428    HONG    Affirmed    03-30-2001
2000001905    29095094    SAUNDERS et al    Reversed    03-29-2001
2000001221    29070030    BONKO    Reversed    02-27-2001

2000

1999001569    29021723    BRUNS    Affirmed    11-22-2000
1995004961    29014077    DAVIS    Reversed    09-06-2000
1999000356    29050057    TANIGUCHI et al    Affirmed    08-23-2000
2000000224    29081424    SANDERS    Affirmed    07-28-2000
2000001348    29092024    CALFEE    Reversed    07-26-2000
2000000244    29069936    SAYERS    Affirmed    07-17-2000
2000000658    29084939    KENNEDY et al    Reversed    06-27-2000
1999002009    29052870    WHITSON    Affirmed    04-20-2000
1998002173    29145835    STANLEY P. FRANKOSKI et al    Affirmed    03-15-2000
2000000543    29066640    KLAYMAN    Affirmed    02-25-2000
1999000410    29063883    SCHREIBER    Affirmed    02-16-2000
2000000553    29079653    MEYER    Affirmed    02-03-2000
1997001343    29039800    RODGERS et al    Reversed    01-06-2000

1999

1999002020    29058031    HARUNA et al    Affirmed    12-20-1999
1998000494    07954056    GARIBOLDI    Reversed    09-20-1999
1997003824    29042728    CASWELL    Reversed    08-31-1999
1999001010    29062011    SOURIS    Affirmed    07-26-1999
1999001024    29062504    ECKMANN    Affirmed    06-30-1999
1996002905    29008076    GRINKUS    Affirmed    06-23-1999
1999000837    29074268    MICHAELI    Affirmed    06-21-1999
1999001439    29033921    JACKSON    Affirmed    06-18-1999
1999000838    29064666    SADLIER et al    Affirmed    06-17-1999
1999001028    29067859    GRINBERG    Affirmed    05-27-1999
1999001018    29054175    STRAND et al    Affirmed    04-29-1999
1999001568    29063397    KIRN et al    Affirmed    04-27-1999
1998002889    29022106    GIAMATI    Affirmed    03-31-1999
1996000211    07929150    FONTAINE    Reversed    03-30-1999
1997004065    29036355    KURREK    Reversed    03-05-1999
1998001906    29045336    STROUGO    Affirmed    03-03-1999
1999000065    29051335    CASTIGLIONE    Affirmed    02-26-1999
1998002888    29044927    VON WEISSENFLUH et al    Affirmed    01-20-1999

1998

1998003079    29052635    CREDLE    Affirmed    12-30-1998
1997002893    29038948    GENATOSSIO et al    Affirmed    10-23-1998
1998001897    07715144    BRIGHT et al    Affirmed    10-05-1998
1998001694    07715261    BRIGHT    Affirmed    10-05-1998
1998001692    07715145    BRIGHT et al    Affirmed    10-05-1998
1998001689    07715259    REGAN et al    Affirmed    10-05-1998
1998001693    07343182    HERCEG et al    Affirmed    10-05-1998
1998001690    07715257    SHEEHAN et al    Affirmed    10-05-1998
1998001691    07715262    WILLIAMS et al    Affirmed    09-29-1998
1998002937    29057491    GALLEOS    Affirmed    09-23-1998
1998000919    29042395    MORSE et al    Affirmed    09-17-1998
1998002069    29052369    GENATOSSIO    Affirmed    08-26-1998
1998002105    29052205    LYNCH    Affirmed    08-25-1998
1998001900    07715260    BRIGHT et al    Affirmed    07-29-1998
1998000070    29019900    RASMUSSEN    Reversed    07-28-1998
1997003184    29048245    HUTCHINS et al    Reversed    06-19-1998
1997003183    29046917    HUTCHINS et al    Reversed    06-16-1998
1997002313    29024479    GALLEGOS    Reversed    05-22-1998
1998000068    29030090    NAGASHIMA    Reversed    05-12-1998
1996003648    07685563    WOLFF    Reversed    04-17-1998
1998000064    29043747    KOVACH et al    Reversed    02-26-1998
1997003411    29029284    DECURSU et al    Reversed    02-19-1998
1996004010    29021122    PEARSON    Reversed    02-19-1998
1995003852    07855945    FUJISAWA    Reversed    02-17-1998

1997
​
1997002581    29031665    PEDERSEN-RASK    Reversed    12-03-1997
1997002464    29038531    VERDURA et al    Reversed    10-23-1997
1996003622    29019382    COCKRAM    Reversed    10-22-1997
1997002867    29012093    HLAVICSKA    Reversed    09-30-1997
1997003204    29024652    KACHMAR    Reversed    09-29-1997
1997002900    29039134    HARDY    Reversed    09-26-1997
1997002461    29020294    FREY    Reversed    09-11-1997
1996003571    29021754    BERTOLINI    Reversed    09-11-1997
1996003568    29009122    LEIGHT    Reversed    09-04-1997
1997002462    29031592    DAVID    Reversed    08-29-1997
1996003210    29025638    SCHRANK et al    Reversed    08-28-1997
1997002440    29036036    CHAVES    Reversed    08-28-1997
1997001566    29033924    SPIEGEL    Reversed    08-26-1997
1996003643    29008022    DAVIS et al    Reversed    08-20-1997
1997000088    29015807    FIGUEROA    Reversed    08-08-1997
1997000649    29031122    NATUZZI et al    Reversed    07-31-1997

PTAB Reexamination Decisions

Series Codes
90  Ex Parte Reexamination
95  Inter Partes Reexamination
96  Supplemental Examination and resulting Ex Parte Reexamination (if instituted)
Notes:   ​
Inter partes reexamination is no longer available after September 15, 2012.  (Replaced by inter partes review).  A request for inter partes reexamination filed on or after September 16, 2011 was not granted unless the information presented in the request established that there was a reasonable likelihood that the requester would prevail with respect to at least one of the claims challenged in the request. This standard replaced the prior standard for granting a request for inter partes reexamination that required a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ) affecting any claim of the patent raised by the request.
Proceeding     Case No.      Case Name

2021002799    90014262    Lerman Container Corporation et al.    Reversed    09-01-2021 (Obviousness rejection reversed) Reasons for Reexamination
2021001988    90013952    David Zahner Zahner Design Group, Ltd. et al.    Affirmed    08-19-2021  Reasons for Reexamination
2020002736    95001540    Sealy Technology LLC et al.    Rehearing Denied    03-01-2021 (Standard for Rehearing not met)
2021000087    90014234    Shuting Zhang et al.   
Reversed    02-16-2021 (102(a) Rejection reversed due to lack of proof internet prior art publicly accessible) Reasons for Reexamination
2020002736    95001540    Sealy Technology LLC et al.    Affirmed    07-01-2020  Reasons for Reexamination
2019004306    95002100    D517,789 et al    Reversed    09-10-2019  Reasons for Reexamination

2018003420    95001549    D622,531 et al    Denied    03-29-2019    Rehearing Decision
2018004259    95001535    D622,088 et al    Denied    03-28-2019    Rehearing Decision​
2018004259    95001535    D622,088 et al    Inter partes reexam new ground of rejection    08-28-2018  Reasons for Reexamination
2018003793    90013497    D559,197 et al    Reversed    07-02-2018  Reasons for Reexamination
2018003420    95001549    D622,531 et al    Affirmed    06-01-2018  Reasons for Reexamination
2015004669    95001793    D536,881 et al    Affirmed    07-30-2015  Reasons for Reexamination
2014007985    95001549    D622,531 et al    Reversed with new ground of rejection    03-31-2015  Reasons for Reexamination
2010004965    90007640    D498,187 et al    Affirmed    06-03-2010  Reasons for Granting
2009002973    95000034    D467,247 et al    Denied    03-22-2010    Rehearing Decision​
2009002973    95000034    D467,247 et al    Reversed    07-30-2009  Reasons for Granting
2005001466    90006515    D437,101 et al    Affirmed    11-30-2005  Reasons for Granting

PTAB Reissue Decisions

Appeal         App             Case Name

2019-4157    29538604    Ex Parte Niklas Vestling et al.    Affirmed    6 Sep 2019

2014-5649    29373729    Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al    Denied    12 Sep 2014    (On Rehearing)
2014-5760    29373730    Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al    Affirmed    28 Jul 2014
2014-5649    29373729    Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al    Affirmed    30 Jun 2014
2002-0494    29102729    Ex Parte Bruce C. Lincoln    Affirmed    27 Jun 2002 
Copyright © 2022, All rights reserved, Robert G. Oake, Jr.,  Oake Law Office, PLLC, 700 S. Central Expressway, Suite 400, Allen, Texas 75013  rgo@oake.com

LEGAL DISCLAIMER: This website is owned and maintained by Oake Law Office, PLLC (the Law Office). The information on this website is general in nature and should not be considered as legal advice or legal opinion.  Although efforts are made to maintain the accuracy of the information on this website, omissions or errors may occur. The Law Office disclaims any liability as to the information on this website.  This website is not an offer to represent you or to perform legal services. An attorney-client relationship with the Law Office only will be established after the Law Office decides that it is willing and able to accept the engagement, and the Law Office and the client enter into a written engagement letter.
  • Home
  • Cases
  • Law
  • Prosecution
  • Litigation