TABLE OF CONTENTS
AIA Trial Cases and Decisions (Inter Partes Review and Post Grant Review)
PTAB Regular Appeal Decisions
PTAB Board Decisions Search (Trials and Appeals)
PTAB Reexamination Decision
PTAB Reissue Decisions
PTAB Regular Appeal Decisions
PTAB Board Decisions Search (Trials and Appeals)
PTAB Reexamination Decision
PTAB Reissue Decisions
Pending AIA Cases (Inter Partes Review and Post Grant Review)
11/09/2021 Laltitude, LLC v. Altus Holdings Incorporated IPR of '138 IPR2022-00155 Pending Institution Decision
10/26/2021 Termax Company v. Illinois Tool Works Inc. IPR of '826 IPR2022-00106 Pending Institution Decision
09/15/2021 IdeaVillage Products Corp. v. Koninklijke Philips N.V. PGR of '346 PGR2021-00116 Pending Institution Decision
06/09/2021 Sattler Tech Corp. v. Yaqi Lyu PGR of '645 PGR2021-00095 Pending Institution Decision
11/09/2021 Laltitude, LLC v. Altus Holdings Incorporated IPR of '138 IPR2022-00155 Pending Institution Decision
10/26/2021 Termax Company v. Illinois Tool Works Inc. IPR of '826 IPR2022-00106 Pending Institution Decision
09/15/2021 IdeaVillage Products Corp. v. Koninklijke Philips N.V. PGR of '346 PGR2021-00116 Pending Institution Decision
06/09/2021 Sattler Tech Corp. v. Yaqi Lyu PGR of '645 PGR2021-00095 Pending Institution Decision
AIA Trial Cases and Decisions (Inter Partes Review and Post Grant Review)
Color Key: Pending Institution Institution Denied Pending Final Decision Final Decision
2021
11/09/2021 Laltitude, LLC v. Altus Holdings Incorporated IPR of '138 IPR2022-00155
10/26/2021 Termax Company v. Illinois Tool Works Inc. IPR of '826 IPR2022-00106
09/15/2021 IdeaVillage Products Corp. v. Koninklijke Philips N.V. PGR of '346 PGR2021-00116
06/09/2021 Sattler Tech Corp. v. Yaqi Lyu PGR of '645 PGR2021-00095
2020
Cell-Pak, Inc. v. Mambate USA, IPR2021-00007 (PTAB Oct 1, 2020) USD846728 Adverse Judgment After Institution
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00055 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD855508
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00054 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD864065
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00823 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD837105
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00821 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD813759
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00536 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD797624
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00534 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD797625
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00530 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD813755
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00022 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD850341
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00020 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD852099
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00024 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD859253
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00021 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD853903
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00023 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD859246
2019
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00064 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD823741 (Final Decision) (Hearing) (Unpatentable)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00004 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD840306
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00065 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD813120 (Withdrawn)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00062 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD811964
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00003 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD847703
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00002 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD847043
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00063 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD828255 (Withdrawn)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00005 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD841532
Sattler Tech Corp. v. HumanCentric Ventures LLC, PGR2019-00030 (PTAB Jan. 15, 2019) USD823093
Man Wah Holdings, Ltd. v. Raffel Systems LLC, IPR2019-00530 (PTAB Jan. 13, 2019) USD643252
Man Wah Holdings, Ltd. v. Raffel Systems LLC, PGR2019-00029 (PTAB Jan. 4, 2019) USD821986
2018
Levitation Arts, Inc. v. Flyte LLC, PGR2018-00073 (PTAB July 3, 2018) USD799100
MacSports Incorporated v. IDEA Nuova Incorporated, IPR2018-01006 (PTAB May 2, 2018) USD752890
2017
C&D Zodiac Incorporated v. B/E Aerospace, Inc., PGR2017-00019 (PTAB April 10, 2017) USD764031
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00607 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD696853
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00608 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD707032
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00619 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD725356
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00617 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723772
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00621 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723781
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00620 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723783
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc. , IPR2017-00623 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD725359
2016
Key-Bar, LLC v. Curv Group, LLC et al, PGR2017-00006 (PTAB Nov. 18, 2016) USD754427
Emerg, LC et al v. Fatboy The Original BV, PGR2017-00004 (PTAB Nov. 17, 2016) USD764823
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00096 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD595074
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00095 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD621644
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00091 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD621645
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00094 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD612646
David's Bridal, Inc. v. Jenny Yoo Collection, Inc., PGR2016-00041 (PTAB Sept. 8, 2016) USD744723
Galaxia Electronics Co., Ltd v. Revolution Display, LLC et al, PGR2016-00021 (PTAB May 18, 2016) USD736750
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01045 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD707032
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01043 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD696853
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01044 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD700423
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00875 (PTAB April 12, 2016) USD723783
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00870 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD725356
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00874 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD723781
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00872 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD723772
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00871 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD725359
Graco Children's Products, Inc. v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00826 (PTAB Mar. 31, 2016) USD616231
Graco Children's Products, Inc. et al v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00816 (PTAB Mar. 30, 2016) USD604970
Graco Children's Products, Inc. et al v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00810 (PTAB Mar. 29, 2016) USD570621
Aristocrat Technologies v. IGT et al, IPR2016-00767 (PTAB Mar. 16, 2016) USD503951
Premier Gem Corp. et al v. Wing Yee Gems & Jewelery Limited et al, IPR2016-00434 (PTAB Jan. 7, 2016) USD618132
2015
Johns Manville Corporation et al v. Knauf Insulation, Inc. et al, IPR2016-00130 (PTAB Nov. 2, 2015) USD631670
Johns Manville Corporation et al v. Knauf Insulation, Inc. et al, IPR2015-01453 (PTAB June 19, 2015) USD631670
Vitro Packaging LLC v. Saverglass Incorporated, IPR2015-00947 (PTAB Mar. 26, 2015) USD526197
2014
Caterpillar Incorporated v. Miller International Incorporated, IPR2015-00416 (PTAB Dec. 22, 2014) USD673982
Lowes Home Centers Incorporated v. Maureen Reddy, IPR2015-00306 (PTAB Nov. 25, 2014) USD677423
Dorman Products Incorporated v. PACCAR Incorporated, IPR2014-00555 (PTAB Mar. 28, 2014) USD526429
Dorman Products Incorporated v. PACCAR Incorporated, IPR2014-00542 (PTAB Mar. 26, 2014) USD525731
2013
Medtronic Incorporated v. NuVasive, Inc., IPR2014-00071 (PTAB Oct. 16, 2013) USD652922
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00580 (PTAB Sept. 11, 2013) USD686447
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00500 (PTAB Aug. 7, 2013) USD669731
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00501 (PTAB Aug. 7, 2013) USD675864
ATAS International Incorporated v. Centria, Inc., IPR2013-00259 (PTAB April 30, 2013) USD527834
2012
Munchkin Incorporated et al v. Luv n' Care Limited, IPR2013-00072 (PTAB Dec. 5, 2012) USD617465
Color Key: Pending Institution Institution Denied Pending Final Decision Final Decision
2021
11/09/2021 Laltitude, LLC v. Altus Holdings Incorporated IPR of '138 IPR2022-00155
10/26/2021 Termax Company v. Illinois Tool Works Inc. IPR of '826 IPR2022-00106
09/15/2021 IdeaVillage Products Corp. v. Koninklijke Philips N.V. PGR of '346 PGR2021-00116
06/09/2021 Sattler Tech Corp. v. Yaqi Lyu PGR of '645 PGR2021-00095
2020
Cell-Pak, Inc. v. Mambate USA, IPR2021-00007 (PTAB Oct 1, 2020) USD846728 Adverse Judgment After Institution
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00055 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD855508
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00054 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD864065
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00823 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD837105
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00821 (PTAB April 8, 2020) USD813759
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00536 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD797624
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00534 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD797625
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00530 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD813755
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00022 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD850341
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00020 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD852099
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00024 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD859253
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00021 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD853903
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00023 (PTAB Feb. 7, 2020) USD859246
2019
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00064 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD823741 (Final Decision) (Hearing) (Unpatentable)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00004 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD840306
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00065 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD813120 (Withdrawn)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00062 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD811964
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00003 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD847703
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00002 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD847043
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, IPR2020-00063 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD828255 (Withdrawn)
LKQ Corporation et al v. GM Global Technology Operations LLC, PGR2020-00005 (PTAB Oct. 17, 2019) USD841532
Sattler Tech Corp. v. HumanCentric Ventures LLC, PGR2019-00030 (PTAB Jan. 15, 2019) USD823093
Man Wah Holdings, Ltd. v. Raffel Systems LLC, IPR2019-00530 (PTAB Jan. 13, 2019) USD643252
Man Wah Holdings, Ltd. v. Raffel Systems LLC, PGR2019-00029 (PTAB Jan. 4, 2019) USD821986
2018
Levitation Arts, Inc. v. Flyte LLC, PGR2018-00073 (PTAB July 3, 2018) USD799100
MacSports Incorporated v. IDEA Nuova Incorporated, IPR2018-01006 (PTAB May 2, 2018) USD752890
2017
C&D Zodiac Incorporated v. B/E Aerospace, Inc., PGR2017-00019 (PTAB April 10, 2017) USD764031
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00607 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD696853
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00608 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD707032
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00619 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD725356
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00617 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723772
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00621 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723781
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2017-00620 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD723783
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc. , IPR2017-00623 (PTAB Jan. 6, 2017) USD725359
2016
Key-Bar, LLC v. Curv Group, LLC et al, PGR2017-00006 (PTAB Nov. 18, 2016) USD754427
Emerg, LC et al v. Fatboy The Original BV, PGR2017-00004 (PTAB Nov. 17, 2016) USD764823
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00096 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD595074
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00095 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD621644
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00091 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD621645
Campbell Soup Company et al v. Gamon Plus, Inc., IPR2017-00094 (PTAB Oct. 14, 2016) USD612646
David's Bridal, Inc. v. Jenny Yoo Collection, Inc., PGR2016-00041 (PTAB Sept. 8, 2016) USD744723
Galaxia Electronics Co., Ltd v. Revolution Display, LLC et al, PGR2016-00021 (PTAB May 18, 2016) USD736750
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01045 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD707032
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01043 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD696853
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-01044 (PTAB May 15, 2016) USD700423
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00875 (PTAB April 12, 2016) USD723783
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00870 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD725356
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00874 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD723781
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00872 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD723772
Skechers USA, Inc. v. Nike, Inc., IPR2016-00871 (PTAB April 11, 2016) USD725359
Graco Children's Products, Inc. v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00826 (PTAB Mar. 31, 2016) USD616231
Graco Children's Products, Inc. et al v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00816 (PTAB Mar. 30, 2016) USD604970
Graco Children's Products, Inc. et al v. Kolcraft Enterprises Incorporated, IPR2016-00810 (PTAB Mar. 29, 2016) USD570621
Aristocrat Technologies v. IGT et al, IPR2016-00767 (PTAB Mar. 16, 2016) USD503951
Premier Gem Corp. et al v. Wing Yee Gems & Jewelery Limited et al, IPR2016-00434 (PTAB Jan. 7, 2016) USD618132
2015
Johns Manville Corporation et al v. Knauf Insulation, Inc. et al, IPR2016-00130 (PTAB Nov. 2, 2015) USD631670
Johns Manville Corporation et al v. Knauf Insulation, Inc. et al, IPR2015-01453 (PTAB June 19, 2015) USD631670
Vitro Packaging LLC v. Saverglass Incorporated, IPR2015-00947 (PTAB Mar. 26, 2015) USD526197
2014
Caterpillar Incorporated v. Miller International Incorporated, IPR2015-00416 (PTAB Dec. 22, 2014) USD673982
Lowes Home Centers Incorporated v. Maureen Reddy, IPR2015-00306 (PTAB Nov. 25, 2014) USD677423
Dorman Products Incorporated v. PACCAR Incorporated, IPR2014-00555 (PTAB Mar. 28, 2014) USD526429
Dorman Products Incorporated v. PACCAR Incorporated, IPR2014-00542 (PTAB Mar. 26, 2014) USD525731
2013
Medtronic Incorporated v. NuVasive, Inc., IPR2014-00071 (PTAB Oct. 16, 2013) USD652922
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00580 (PTAB Sept. 11, 2013) USD686447
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00500 (PTAB Aug. 7, 2013) USD669731
Sensio Incorporated v. Select Brands Incorporated, IPR2013-00501 (PTAB Aug. 7, 2013) USD675864
ATAS International Incorporated v. Centria, Inc., IPR2013-00259 (PTAB April 30, 2013) USD527834
2012
Munchkin Incorporated et al v. Luv n' Care Limited, IPR2013-00072 (PTAB Dec. 5, 2012) USD617465
PTAB Regular Appeal Decisions
Proceeding Application Appellant Decision Date Issues
2021
2021002735 29641286 HFA, Inc. Reversed 4-15-2021 (Obviousness - Primary prior art reference not basically the same)
2020001447 35502286 Weiss Umwelttechnik GmbH Affirmed 03-16-2021 (Lack of Written Description and Indefiniteness of computer icons)
2020
2019002498 35500407 Flos s.p.a. Reversed 10-26-2020
2019002407 35500409 Flos s.p.a. Reversed 10-21-2020
2019004375 29570334 Bredemeier, Lori A. et al. Reversed 07-16-2020 (Reversal of Section 112 written description rejection based on alleged new matter)
2019004511 29543707 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Reversed 07-10-2020
2019007012 29619971 Bliss Hammocks Inc. Reversed 07-07-2020
2019006598 29361552 Shawn Fojtik Reversed 06-02-2020
2018007626 29543700 George Bucher et al. Reversed 05-26-2020
2019004749 29572562 Amazon Technologies, Inc. Reversed 05-21-2020
2019004293 29598496 Eichler, Mark Joseph. Reversed 05-01-2020
2019004315 29531964 Amazon Technologies, Inc. Reversed 04-24-2020
2018007433 29580932 Jay Sato et al. Reversed 03-31-2020
2019001458 29515499 Perez, Jose Reversed 03-30-2020
2019002084 29453864 Jaewoong Chung Reversed 03-27-2020
2019003730 29535082 Piper, Neal Reversed 03-27-2020
2018007742 29430805 Antonio Chioccioni Reversed 03-24-2020 (Reversal of Section 112 indefiniteness and non-enabling rejection)
2019002406 29525529 Paul W. Adam Affirmed 03-20-2020 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2019001727 29534975 Fong, Alena Rose. et al. Reversed 01-27-2020
2018001761 29360842 Michael O. English et al. Reversed 01-17-2020
2019001591 29547573 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 01-03-2020
2019001551 29547564 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 01-03-2020
2019
2018005551 29408999 Birgers, Christopher J. et al. Reversed 12-31-2019
2018005678 29409740 Birgers, Christopher J. et al. Reversed 12-31-2019
2018003279 29453426 Vittorio Bologna et al. Affirmed 12-27-2019
2019000370 29509362 Yasutomi, Hiroshi et al. Affirmed 12-19-2019 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2018001766 29443590 Imran Chaudhri et al. Reversed 12-19-2019
2019001875 29541104 Apple Inc. Reversed 12-18-2019
2018001345 29495451 Juan Almajid Affirmed 10-23-2019 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2019001548 29547557 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001547 29547549 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001578 29547546 SALAS, LUIS F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001549 29547559 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001546 29547547 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2018006442 29497580 Ahren Bonnema et al. Reversed 09-26-2019
2018004712 29461783 Danielle Giza Reversed 09-24-2019
2019001776 29522397 Mohageg, Mike et al. Reversed 09-20-2019
2019001901 29494441 Mariet, Robertus Christianus Elisabeth. et al. Reversed 09-19-2019
2019001900 29461780 Giza, Danielle Reversed 09-17-2019
2018
2017004757 14012735 Matt Alirol Affirmed 01-16-2018
2017
2016000765 10943433 Richard E. Fulton et al Affirmed-in-Part 08-21-2017
2014001032 29275866 Jennifer L. Sadler et al Reversed 02-22-2017
2016
2013003740 29379528 Joseph P. Schultz Reversed 06-30-2016
2014002624 29283341 Robert Ball Reversed 04-18-2016
2014001432 29336285 Kathleen H. WITSIL et al Reversed 03-08-2016
2014001431 29336284 Kathleen H. WITSIL et al Reversed 03-08-2016
2014001433 29336290 Kathleen H. WITSIL et al Reversed 03-08-2016
2015
2012012651 29370780 Jiaolong Chen Reversed 08-31-2015
2014
2011011390 11000849 Geoff Smith et al Reversed 03-31-2014
2012
2010002075 29237687 Bartley K. Andre et al Reversed 04-19-2012
2010005623 29289864 Christopher J. Terrels et al Reversed 02-21-2012
2011
2010001119 29276899 LARS ROSAEN Reversed 12-19-2011
2010000696 29176577 Robert J. Libman et al Reversed 11-02-2011
2009013647 29176106 Jamie L. Wheat Reversed 06-20-2011
2010
2010002291 29271282 Peter M.H. Hung Reversed 09-07-2010
2009010416 29264402 Jamie Chauss et al Reversed 08-31-2010
2009012678 29212644 Paul Lacotta et al Reversed 06-02-2010
2010000272 29196576 Allison M. Hart et al Reversed 04-06-2010
2009009601 29241338 Aaron Charles Cueto Reversed 01-22-2010
2009
2009009310 29302817 Robert Finch Kellermann et al Reversed 10-22-2009
2009009305 29302816 Robert Finch Kellermann et al Reversed 10-21-2009
2009005005 29244885 Troutman, Damon Oliver Casati. et al. Reversed 09-23-2009
2009010408 29236287 Stefano Bettocchi Reversed 09-15-2009
2009002192 10943433 Richard E. Fulton et al Reversed 07-31-2009
2009010242 29192232 Philip W. Wyers Reversed 07-20-2009
2008005555 29226865 Gordon E. VerWeyst Reversed 03-25-2009
2008005613 29196598 Robert T. Mitten et al Reversed 02-26-2009
2008
2008002254 29222088 Makoto Ishii et al Reversed 11-26-2008
2008002270 29174064 Frank Howard Schaller Reversed 06-02-2008
2007004521 29177452 Scott M. Risdon et al Reversed 01-29-2008
2007
2007001759 29206334 Michael K. Kuehne et al Reversed 07-11-2007
2006
2006000475 29158008 Richard B. Manville Reversed 02-27-2006
2004
2004001452 29138830 William K. Stout JR. Reversed 08-31-2004
2004001305 29138829 William K. Stout JR. Reversed 08-27-2004
2004000152 29149571 Stefan Sagmeister et al Reversed 03-15-2004
2004000401 29160956 Charles Pomeroy et al Reversed 02-25-2004
2003001862 29153657 Stuart J. Ledingham Reversed 01-29-2004
2003
2003001760 29159145 Arthur Miller Reversed 09-26-2003
2003000656 29124773 Richard A. Cruz Reversed 03-27-2003
2001000261 29066640 None Reversed 02-27-2003
2002001818 29094432 COUNTEE Reversed 01-16-2003
2003000007 29092219 DEWALD Reversed 01-16-2003
2002002307 29105570 BERTIERI Reversed 01-10-2003
1999001013 29014141 FRATTAROLA Affirmed 01-03-2003
2002
2003000043 29065720 JAMES A. RIEDL Reversed 11-26-2002
2002002156 29113438 KEMP et al Reversed 11-19-2002
2001000292 29076553 KRUNAS Reversed 10-31-2002
2001000961 08108133 DUKE Reversed 10-30-2002
2000002150 29083483 MCGOVERN et al Reversed 07-29-2002
2001
2001002294 29097935 VITTORIO GRAZIOLI Reversed 12-17-2001
2001000337 29091083 GOLDEN et al Reversed 08-29-2001
2000002151 29099783 NOSELLA Reversed 05-22-2001
2001000467 29100490 BERTANI Reversed 05-11-2001
2001000466 29112628 ROWAN Reversed 04-26-2001
2000002183 29082343 GRANT Reversed 04-23-2001
1999001567 29035428 HONG Affirmed 03-30-2001
2000001905 29095094 SAUNDERS et al Reversed 03-29-2001
2000001221 29070030 BONKO Reversed 02-27-2001
2000
1999001569 29021723 BRUNS Affirmed 11-22-2000
1995004961 29014077 DAVIS Reversed 09-06-2000
1999000356 29050057 TANIGUCHI et al Affirmed 08-23-2000
2000000224 29081424 SANDERS Affirmed 07-28-2000
2000001348 29092024 CALFEE Reversed 07-26-2000
2000000244 29069936 SAYERS Affirmed 07-17-2000
2000000658 29084939 KENNEDY et al Reversed 06-27-2000
1999002009 29052870 WHITSON Affirmed 04-20-2000
1998002173 29145835 STANLEY P. FRANKOSKI et al Affirmed 03-15-2000
2000000543 29066640 KLAYMAN Affirmed 02-25-2000
1999000410 29063883 SCHREIBER Affirmed 02-16-2000
2000000553 29079653 MEYER Affirmed 02-03-2000
1997001343 29039800 RODGERS et al Reversed 01-06-2000
1999
1999002020 29058031 HARUNA et al Affirmed 12-20-1999
1998000494 07954056 GARIBOLDI Reversed 09-20-1999
1997003824 29042728 CASWELL Reversed 08-31-1999
1999001010 29062011 SOURIS Affirmed 07-26-1999
1999001024 29062504 ECKMANN Affirmed 06-30-1999
1996002905 29008076 GRINKUS Affirmed 06-23-1999
1999000837 29074268 MICHAELI Affirmed 06-21-1999
1999001439 29033921 JACKSON Affirmed 06-18-1999
1999000838 29064666 SADLIER et al Affirmed 06-17-1999
1999001028 29067859 GRINBERG Affirmed 05-27-1999
1999001018 29054175 STRAND et al Affirmed 04-29-1999
1999001568 29063397 KIRN et al Affirmed 04-27-1999
1998002889 29022106 GIAMATI Affirmed 03-31-1999
1996000211 07929150 FONTAINE Reversed 03-30-1999
1997004065 29036355 KURREK Reversed 03-05-1999
1998001906 29045336 STROUGO Affirmed 03-03-1999
1999000065 29051335 CASTIGLIONE Affirmed 02-26-1999
1998002888 29044927 VON WEISSENFLUH et al Affirmed 01-20-1999
1998
1998003079 29052635 CREDLE Affirmed 12-30-1998
1997002893 29038948 GENATOSSIO et al Affirmed 10-23-1998
1998001897 07715144 BRIGHT et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001694 07715261 BRIGHT Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001692 07715145 BRIGHT et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001689 07715259 REGAN et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001693 07343182 HERCEG et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001690 07715257 SHEEHAN et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001691 07715262 WILLIAMS et al Affirmed 09-29-1998
1998002937 29057491 GALLEOS Affirmed 09-23-1998
1998000919 29042395 MORSE et al Affirmed 09-17-1998
1998002069 29052369 GENATOSSIO Affirmed 08-26-1998
1998002105 29052205 LYNCH Affirmed 08-25-1998
1998001900 07715260 BRIGHT et al Affirmed 07-29-1998
1998000070 29019900 RASMUSSEN Reversed 07-28-1998
1997003184 29048245 HUTCHINS et al Reversed 06-19-1998
1997003183 29046917 HUTCHINS et al Reversed 06-16-1998
1997002313 29024479 GALLEGOS Reversed 05-22-1998
1998000068 29030090 NAGASHIMA Reversed 05-12-1998
1996003648 07685563 WOLFF Reversed 04-17-1998
1998000064 29043747 KOVACH et al Reversed 02-26-1998
1997003411 29029284 DECURSU et al Reversed 02-19-1998
1996004010 29021122 PEARSON Reversed 02-19-1998
1995003852 07855945 FUJISAWA Reversed 02-17-1998
1997
1997002581 29031665 PEDERSEN-RASK Reversed 12-03-1997
1997002464 29038531 VERDURA et al Reversed 10-23-1997
1996003622 29019382 COCKRAM Reversed 10-22-1997
1997002867 29012093 HLAVICSKA Reversed 09-30-1997
1997003204 29024652 KACHMAR Reversed 09-29-1997
1997002900 29039134 HARDY Reversed 09-26-1997
1997002461 29020294 FREY Reversed 09-11-1997
1996003571 29021754 BERTOLINI Reversed 09-11-1997
1996003568 29009122 LEIGHT Reversed 09-04-1997
1997002462 29031592 DAVID Reversed 08-29-1997
1996003210 29025638 SCHRANK et al Reversed 08-28-1997
1997002440 29036036 CHAVES Reversed 08-28-1997
1997001566 29033924 SPIEGEL Reversed 08-26-1997
1996003643 29008022 DAVIS et al Reversed 08-20-1997
1997000088 29015807 FIGUEROA Reversed 08-08-1997
1997000649 29031122 NATUZZI et al Reversed 07-31-1997
2021
2021002735 29641286 HFA, Inc. Reversed 4-15-2021 (Obviousness - Primary prior art reference not basically the same)
2020001447 35502286 Weiss Umwelttechnik GmbH Affirmed 03-16-2021 (Lack of Written Description and Indefiniteness of computer icons)
2020
2019002498 35500407 Flos s.p.a. Reversed 10-26-2020
2019002407 35500409 Flos s.p.a. Reversed 10-21-2020
2019004375 29570334 Bredemeier, Lori A. et al. Reversed 07-16-2020 (Reversal of Section 112 written description rejection based on alleged new matter)
2019004511 29543707 Honda Motor Co., Ltd. Reversed 07-10-2020
2019007012 29619971 Bliss Hammocks Inc. Reversed 07-07-2020
2019006598 29361552 Shawn Fojtik Reversed 06-02-2020
2018007626 29543700 George Bucher et al. Reversed 05-26-2020
2019004749 29572562 Amazon Technologies, Inc. Reversed 05-21-2020
2019004293 29598496 Eichler, Mark Joseph. Reversed 05-01-2020
2019004315 29531964 Amazon Technologies, Inc. Reversed 04-24-2020
2018007433 29580932 Jay Sato et al. Reversed 03-31-2020
2019001458 29515499 Perez, Jose Reversed 03-30-2020
2019002084 29453864 Jaewoong Chung Reversed 03-27-2020
2019003730 29535082 Piper, Neal Reversed 03-27-2020
2018007742 29430805 Antonio Chioccioni Reversed 03-24-2020 (Reversal of Section 112 indefiniteness and non-enabling rejection)
2019002406 29525529 Paul W. Adam Affirmed 03-20-2020 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2019001727 29534975 Fong, Alena Rose. et al. Reversed 01-27-2020
2018001761 29360842 Michael O. English et al. Reversed 01-17-2020
2019001591 29547573 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 01-03-2020
2019001551 29547564 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 01-03-2020
2019
2018005551 29408999 Birgers, Christopher J. et al. Reversed 12-31-2019
2018005678 29409740 Birgers, Christopher J. et al. Reversed 12-31-2019
2018003279 29453426 Vittorio Bologna et al. Affirmed 12-27-2019
2019000370 29509362 Yasutomi, Hiroshi et al. Affirmed 12-19-2019 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2018001766 29443590 Imran Chaudhri et al. Reversed 12-19-2019
2019001875 29541104 Apple Inc. Reversed 12-18-2019
2018001345 29495451 Juan Almajid Affirmed 10-23-2019 (Section 112 drawing inconsistencies)
2019001548 29547557 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001547 29547549 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001578 29547546 SALAS, LUIS F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001549 29547559 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2019001546 29547547 Salas, Luis F. et al. Reversed 10-01-2019
2018006442 29497580 Ahren Bonnema et al. Reversed 09-26-2019
2018004712 29461783 Danielle Giza Reversed 09-24-2019
2019001776 29522397 Mohageg, Mike et al. Reversed 09-20-2019
2019001901 29494441 Mariet, Robertus Christianus Elisabeth. et al. Reversed 09-19-2019
2019001900 29461780 Giza, Danielle Reversed 09-17-2019
2018
2017004757 14012735 Matt Alirol Affirmed 01-16-2018
2017
2016000765 10943433 Richard E. Fulton et al Affirmed-in-Part 08-21-2017
2014001032 29275866 Jennifer L. Sadler et al Reversed 02-22-2017
2016
2013003740 29379528 Joseph P. Schultz Reversed 06-30-2016
2014002624 29283341 Robert Ball Reversed 04-18-2016
2014001432 29336285 Kathleen H. WITSIL et al Reversed 03-08-2016
2014001431 29336284 Kathleen H. WITSIL et al Reversed 03-08-2016
2014001433 29336290 Kathleen H. WITSIL et al Reversed 03-08-2016
2015
2012012651 29370780 Jiaolong Chen Reversed 08-31-2015
2014
2011011390 11000849 Geoff Smith et al Reversed 03-31-2014
2012
2010002075 29237687 Bartley K. Andre et al Reversed 04-19-2012
2010005623 29289864 Christopher J. Terrels et al Reversed 02-21-2012
2011
2010001119 29276899 LARS ROSAEN Reversed 12-19-2011
2010000696 29176577 Robert J. Libman et al Reversed 11-02-2011
2009013647 29176106 Jamie L. Wheat Reversed 06-20-2011
2010
2010002291 29271282 Peter M.H. Hung Reversed 09-07-2010
2009010416 29264402 Jamie Chauss et al Reversed 08-31-2010
2009012678 29212644 Paul Lacotta et al Reversed 06-02-2010
2010000272 29196576 Allison M. Hart et al Reversed 04-06-2010
2009009601 29241338 Aaron Charles Cueto Reversed 01-22-2010
2009
2009009310 29302817 Robert Finch Kellermann et al Reversed 10-22-2009
2009009305 29302816 Robert Finch Kellermann et al Reversed 10-21-2009
2009005005 29244885 Troutman, Damon Oliver Casati. et al. Reversed 09-23-2009
2009010408 29236287 Stefano Bettocchi Reversed 09-15-2009
2009002192 10943433 Richard E. Fulton et al Reversed 07-31-2009
2009010242 29192232 Philip W. Wyers Reversed 07-20-2009
2008005555 29226865 Gordon E. VerWeyst Reversed 03-25-2009
2008005613 29196598 Robert T. Mitten et al Reversed 02-26-2009
2008
2008002254 29222088 Makoto Ishii et al Reversed 11-26-2008
2008002270 29174064 Frank Howard Schaller Reversed 06-02-2008
2007004521 29177452 Scott M. Risdon et al Reversed 01-29-2008
2007
2007001759 29206334 Michael K. Kuehne et al Reversed 07-11-2007
2006
2006000475 29158008 Richard B. Manville Reversed 02-27-2006
2004
2004001452 29138830 William K. Stout JR. Reversed 08-31-2004
2004001305 29138829 William K. Stout JR. Reversed 08-27-2004
2004000152 29149571 Stefan Sagmeister et al Reversed 03-15-2004
2004000401 29160956 Charles Pomeroy et al Reversed 02-25-2004
2003001862 29153657 Stuart J. Ledingham Reversed 01-29-2004
2003
2003001760 29159145 Arthur Miller Reversed 09-26-2003
2003000656 29124773 Richard A. Cruz Reversed 03-27-2003
2001000261 29066640 None Reversed 02-27-2003
2002001818 29094432 COUNTEE Reversed 01-16-2003
2003000007 29092219 DEWALD Reversed 01-16-2003
2002002307 29105570 BERTIERI Reversed 01-10-2003
1999001013 29014141 FRATTAROLA Affirmed 01-03-2003
2002
2003000043 29065720 JAMES A. RIEDL Reversed 11-26-2002
2002002156 29113438 KEMP et al Reversed 11-19-2002
2001000292 29076553 KRUNAS Reversed 10-31-2002
2001000961 08108133 DUKE Reversed 10-30-2002
2000002150 29083483 MCGOVERN et al Reversed 07-29-2002
2001
2001002294 29097935 VITTORIO GRAZIOLI Reversed 12-17-2001
2001000337 29091083 GOLDEN et al Reversed 08-29-2001
2000002151 29099783 NOSELLA Reversed 05-22-2001
2001000467 29100490 BERTANI Reversed 05-11-2001
2001000466 29112628 ROWAN Reversed 04-26-2001
2000002183 29082343 GRANT Reversed 04-23-2001
1999001567 29035428 HONG Affirmed 03-30-2001
2000001905 29095094 SAUNDERS et al Reversed 03-29-2001
2000001221 29070030 BONKO Reversed 02-27-2001
2000
1999001569 29021723 BRUNS Affirmed 11-22-2000
1995004961 29014077 DAVIS Reversed 09-06-2000
1999000356 29050057 TANIGUCHI et al Affirmed 08-23-2000
2000000224 29081424 SANDERS Affirmed 07-28-2000
2000001348 29092024 CALFEE Reversed 07-26-2000
2000000244 29069936 SAYERS Affirmed 07-17-2000
2000000658 29084939 KENNEDY et al Reversed 06-27-2000
1999002009 29052870 WHITSON Affirmed 04-20-2000
1998002173 29145835 STANLEY P. FRANKOSKI et al Affirmed 03-15-2000
2000000543 29066640 KLAYMAN Affirmed 02-25-2000
1999000410 29063883 SCHREIBER Affirmed 02-16-2000
2000000553 29079653 MEYER Affirmed 02-03-2000
1997001343 29039800 RODGERS et al Reversed 01-06-2000
1999
1999002020 29058031 HARUNA et al Affirmed 12-20-1999
1998000494 07954056 GARIBOLDI Reversed 09-20-1999
1997003824 29042728 CASWELL Reversed 08-31-1999
1999001010 29062011 SOURIS Affirmed 07-26-1999
1999001024 29062504 ECKMANN Affirmed 06-30-1999
1996002905 29008076 GRINKUS Affirmed 06-23-1999
1999000837 29074268 MICHAELI Affirmed 06-21-1999
1999001439 29033921 JACKSON Affirmed 06-18-1999
1999000838 29064666 SADLIER et al Affirmed 06-17-1999
1999001028 29067859 GRINBERG Affirmed 05-27-1999
1999001018 29054175 STRAND et al Affirmed 04-29-1999
1999001568 29063397 KIRN et al Affirmed 04-27-1999
1998002889 29022106 GIAMATI Affirmed 03-31-1999
1996000211 07929150 FONTAINE Reversed 03-30-1999
1997004065 29036355 KURREK Reversed 03-05-1999
1998001906 29045336 STROUGO Affirmed 03-03-1999
1999000065 29051335 CASTIGLIONE Affirmed 02-26-1999
1998002888 29044927 VON WEISSENFLUH et al Affirmed 01-20-1999
1998
1998003079 29052635 CREDLE Affirmed 12-30-1998
1997002893 29038948 GENATOSSIO et al Affirmed 10-23-1998
1998001897 07715144 BRIGHT et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001694 07715261 BRIGHT Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001692 07715145 BRIGHT et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001689 07715259 REGAN et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001693 07343182 HERCEG et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001690 07715257 SHEEHAN et al Affirmed 10-05-1998
1998001691 07715262 WILLIAMS et al Affirmed 09-29-1998
1998002937 29057491 GALLEOS Affirmed 09-23-1998
1998000919 29042395 MORSE et al Affirmed 09-17-1998
1998002069 29052369 GENATOSSIO Affirmed 08-26-1998
1998002105 29052205 LYNCH Affirmed 08-25-1998
1998001900 07715260 BRIGHT et al Affirmed 07-29-1998
1998000070 29019900 RASMUSSEN Reversed 07-28-1998
1997003184 29048245 HUTCHINS et al Reversed 06-19-1998
1997003183 29046917 HUTCHINS et al Reversed 06-16-1998
1997002313 29024479 GALLEGOS Reversed 05-22-1998
1998000068 29030090 NAGASHIMA Reversed 05-12-1998
1996003648 07685563 WOLFF Reversed 04-17-1998
1998000064 29043747 KOVACH et al Reversed 02-26-1998
1997003411 29029284 DECURSU et al Reversed 02-19-1998
1996004010 29021122 PEARSON Reversed 02-19-1998
1995003852 07855945 FUJISAWA Reversed 02-17-1998
1997
1997002581 29031665 PEDERSEN-RASK Reversed 12-03-1997
1997002464 29038531 VERDURA et al Reversed 10-23-1997
1996003622 29019382 COCKRAM Reversed 10-22-1997
1997002867 29012093 HLAVICSKA Reversed 09-30-1997
1997003204 29024652 KACHMAR Reversed 09-29-1997
1997002900 29039134 HARDY Reversed 09-26-1997
1997002461 29020294 FREY Reversed 09-11-1997
1996003571 29021754 BERTOLINI Reversed 09-11-1997
1996003568 29009122 LEIGHT Reversed 09-04-1997
1997002462 29031592 DAVID Reversed 08-29-1997
1996003210 29025638 SCHRANK et al Reversed 08-28-1997
1997002440 29036036 CHAVES Reversed 08-28-1997
1997001566 29033924 SPIEGEL Reversed 08-26-1997
1996003643 29008022 DAVIS et al Reversed 08-20-1997
1997000088 29015807 FIGUEROA Reversed 08-08-1997
1997000649 29031122 NATUZZI et al Reversed 07-31-1997
PTAB Reexamination Decisions
Series Codes
90 Ex Parte Reexamination
95 Inter Partes Reexamination
96 Supplemental Examination and resulting Ex Parte Reexamination (if instituted)
Notes:
Inter partes reexamination is no longer available after September 15, 2012. (Replaced by inter partes review). A request for inter partes reexamination filed on or after September 16, 2011 was not granted unless the information presented in the request established that there was a reasonable likelihood that the requester would prevail with respect to at least one of the claims challenged in the request. This standard replaced the prior standard for granting a request for inter partes reexamination that required a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ) affecting any claim of the patent raised by the request.
90 Ex Parte Reexamination
95 Inter Partes Reexamination
96 Supplemental Examination and resulting Ex Parte Reexamination (if instituted)
Notes:
Inter partes reexamination is no longer available after September 15, 2012. (Replaced by inter partes review). A request for inter partes reexamination filed on or after September 16, 2011 was not granted unless the information presented in the request established that there was a reasonable likelihood that the requester would prevail with respect to at least one of the claims challenged in the request. This standard replaced the prior standard for granting a request for inter partes reexamination that required a substantial new question of patentability (SNQ) affecting any claim of the patent raised by the request.
Proceeding Case No. Case Name
2021002799 90014262 Lerman Container Corporation et al. Reversed 09-01-2021 (Obviousness rejection reversed) Reasons for Reexamination
2021001988 90013952 David Zahner Zahner Design Group, Ltd. et al. Affirmed 08-19-2021 Reasons for Reexamination
2020002736 95001540 Sealy Technology LLC et al. Rehearing Denied 03-01-2021 (Standard for Rehearing not met)
2021000087 90014234 Shuting Zhang et al. Reversed 02-16-2021 (102(a) Rejection reversed due to lack of proof internet prior art publicly accessible) Reasons for Reexamination
2020002736 95001540 Sealy Technology LLC et al. Affirmed 07-01-2020 Reasons for Reexamination
2019004306 95002100 D517,789 et al Reversed 09-10-2019 Reasons for Reexamination
2018003420 95001549 D622,531 et al Denied 03-29-2019 Rehearing Decision
2018004259 95001535 D622,088 et al Denied 03-28-2019 Rehearing Decision
2018004259 95001535 D622,088 et al Inter partes reexam new ground of rejection 08-28-2018 Reasons for Reexamination
2018003793 90013497 D559,197 et al Reversed 07-02-2018 Reasons for Reexamination
2018003420 95001549 D622,531 et al Affirmed 06-01-2018 Reasons for Reexamination
2015004669 95001793 D536,881 et al Affirmed 07-30-2015 Reasons for Reexamination
2014007985 95001549 D622,531 et al Reversed with new ground of rejection 03-31-2015 Reasons for Reexamination
2010004965 90007640 D498,187 et al Affirmed 06-03-2010 Reasons for Granting
2009002973 95000034 D467,247 et al Denied 03-22-2010 Rehearing Decision
2009002973 95000034 D467,247 et al Reversed 07-30-2009 Reasons for Granting
2005001466 90006515 D437,101 et al Affirmed 11-30-2005 Reasons for Granting
2021002799 90014262 Lerman Container Corporation et al. Reversed 09-01-2021 (Obviousness rejection reversed) Reasons for Reexamination
2021001988 90013952 David Zahner Zahner Design Group, Ltd. et al. Affirmed 08-19-2021 Reasons for Reexamination
2020002736 95001540 Sealy Technology LLC et al. Rehearing Denied 03-01-2021 (Standard for Rehearing not met)
2021000087 90014234 Shuting Zhang et al. Reversed 02-16-2021 (102(a) Rejection reversed due to lack of proof internet prior art publicly accessible) Reasons for Reexamination
2020002736 95001540 Sealy Technology LLC et al. Affirmed 07-01-2020 Reasons for Reexamination
2019004306 95002100 D517,789 et al Reversed 09-10-2019 Reasons for Reexamination
2018003420 95001549 D622,531 et al Denied 03-29-2019 Rehearing Decision
2018004259 95001535 D622,088 et al Denied 03-28-2019 Rehearing Decision
2018004259 95001535 D622,088 et al Inter partes reexam new ground of rejection 08-28-2018 Reasons for Reexamination
2018003793 90013497 D559,197 et al Reversed 07-02-2018 Reasons for Reexamination
2018003420 95001549 D622,531 et al Affirmed 06-01-2018 Reasons for Reexamination
2015004669 95001793 D536,881 et al Affirmed 07-30-2015 Reasons for Reexamination
2014007985 95001549 D622,531 et al Reversed with new ground of rejection 03-31-2015 Reasons for Reexamination
2010004965 90007640 D498,187 et al Affirmed 06-03-2010 Reasons for Granting
2009002973 95000034 D467,247 et al Denied 03-22-2010 Rehearing Decision
2009002973 95000034 D467,247 et al Reversed 07-30-2009 Reasons for Granting
2005001466 90006515 D437,101 et al Affirmed 11-30-2005 Reasons for Granting
PTAB Reissue Decisions
Appeal App Case Name
2019-4157 29538604 Ex Parte Niklas Vestling et al. Affirmed 6 Sep 2019
2014-5649 29373729 Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al Denied 12 Sep 2014 (On Rehearing)
2014-5760 29373730 Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al Affirmed 28 Jul 2014
2014-5649 29373729 Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al Affirmed 30 Jun 2014
2002-0494 29102729 Ex Parte Bruce C. Lincoln Affirmed 27 Jun 2002
2019-4157 29538604 Ex Parte Niklas Vestling et al. Affirmed 6 Sep 2019
2014-5649 29373729 Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al Denied 12 Sep 2014 (On Rehearing)
2014-5760 29373730 Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al Affirmed 28 Jul 2014
2014-5649 29373729 Ex Parte Richard A. Carlow et al Affirmed 30 Jun 2014
2002-0494 29102729 Ex Parte Bruce C. Lincoln Affirmed 27 Jun 2002